Welcome to The Original NY Pizza
The Original NY Pizza, located at 6458 Tryon Rd, Cary, NC, is a culinary gem that brings a slice of New York to the South. This pizzeria captures the essence of authentic NYC pizza with its thin, crispy crust, ample sauce, and rich cheese. Patrons rave about its hearty calzones and the flavorful Sicilian slices, making it a go-to spot for both locals and visitors. The welcoming staff contributes to a warm, friendly atmosphere adorned with nostalgic NYC imagery. Many customers, including transplants from New York, affirm that it rivals the best pizzerias in the city, offering a true taste of New York in every bite.
The Original NY Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Great pizza and other items like calzones. I'm from New York City, born and bred. To me, this is not a real Italian NYC pizza. But it is however very delicious pizza, the best that I can get outside of NYC.
It gives an NYC pizza vibe for sure the kids love it and they call it juicy pizza. Service is great and cool crew a lot of pictures of nyc and the culture
One of the best NY pizza places in the south. From a New Yorker.
This is one of my favorite lunch spots. I come here about once a week for the 2-slice-plus-drink combo. Both the thin slices and Sicilian slices are very tasty. The full sized pies are also great for a group. The staff is also SUPER friendly!
Being from NY, I know NY style pizza. Many pizza places not in NY claim to have NY style pizza, and few do. If you want true NY style pizza at a fair price for this level of quality, go to this restaurant! The crust is thin, with lots of sauce and lots of cheese. The folks working here are hard-working, polite, friendly, and cheerful. Living an hour away, we have to take our dog to this area for a heart test every 6 months. The man here remembered me from 6 months ago!!! That is amazing in itself. We will have lunch here every time we are in this area as we have tried many pizza places around our home, most all don't come close to this pizza shop. Thank you to those working here, for making our day nicer and our meal great!
love this place, by far my favorite spot to get a slice or two :) everyone here is SOOOO NICEEE like literally EVERYONE and the pizza is always awesome. garlic knots are incredible too. shoutout for always having baseball on, watched shohei play while i waited for my order :)
The name is not a gimmick. This is the Real deal. I'd say this is the best pizza within 100miles of Raleigh. One of the best pizzas I've ever had and I've been around the country and world. The crust has just the right crisp. The cheese and sauce are on point. This place is clean. The service is polite and professional. The owner/management clearly take pride it their food.
Haven't had NY pizza since the 1980's. From the moment I walked in and smelled it, I knew it was NY pizza. I was delighted. Too bad I was stopping by and live in Williamston. I invite you folks to open a pizzeria in Greenville, NC. Thank you
Location
-
6458 Tryon Rd, Cary, NC 27518, United States Hotline: +1 919-852-2242
The Original NY Pizza, located at 6458 Tryon Rd in Cary, NC, has carved a niche for itself as a beacon of New York-style pizza in the heart of the South. With a phone number available for inquiries at +1 919-852-2242, this establishment promises a culinary experience that combines authenticity and a touch of local charm.
Notable for its thin, crispy crust and generous layers of sauce and cheese, The Original NY Pizza has received glowing reviews from both locals and transplants from New York. As Hector Morales, a native New Yorker, reflects, "To me, this is not a real Italian NYC pizza. But it is, however, very delicious pizza." His sentiment captures the essence of this place: it may not be the exact replica of the Big Apple's iconic slices, but it's a worthy contender that delights the taste buds.
Patrons rave about the restaurant's inviting vibe. Diamond Coram shares, "It gives an NYC pizza vibe for sure," noting that her kids affectionately call it "juicy pizza." The decor, adorned with photographs of New York City, adds to the nostalgia and authenticity of the experience. This ambiance, coupled with the friendly service, creates a warm and welcoming atmosphere where guests feel right at home.
One customer, Andrew Knight, commends the consistency of their offerings, highlighting the "2-slice-plus-drink combo" that has become a staple for his weekly lunches. Both the traditional thin slices and Sicilian variations receive accolades for their flavor, making them perfect for solo diners or groups alike. The lively spirit of the staff enhances the overall enjoyment, as they are known for their cheerful demeanor and attentiveness.
Commander-RR, another satisfied customer, emphasizes the establishment's commitment to quality, stating, "If you want true NY-style pizza at a fair price, go to this restaurant!" The dedication to serving superior pizza has garnered a loyal following, with patrons making return visits, even traveling long distances for a meal. The sense of community and familiarity that the staff cultivate is evident, making every visit feel special.
If you're in Cary, NC, and craving a taste of New York, The Original NY Pizza is a must-try. With its delicious offerings, friendly service, and inviting atmosphere, it stands as a testament to the enduring appeal of classic NYC pizza. Come for the slices, stay for the experience—we promise it will be a treat for your taste buds!